The Coy Pond: A Question Of Character

mayeko:

dangerous-ladies:

mayeko:

Batman. I am so sick and tired of Batman. I don’t know if I’m just transferring my distaste for Bob Kane or my personal history and introduction to Batman mythos (basically I watched Batman Beyond and anyone in the suit that wasn’t Terry and any Bruce that wasn’t Old Bruce became a let down) or that I reached my Batman saturation point early on or any number of reasons I’ve managed to pull up to defend myself when people try to fight me about it. Maybe one day when I will write a well constructed paper about why exactly I hate Bruce Wayne and the culture surrounding him, but I hate essay writing more than any fiction character in existence.

I’m not even stating I hate all Batman stories or the rest of the Gotham crew, there are plenty of great Batman stories out there, I just don’t like Batman himself. Also listening to everyone go on about how incredibly badass and untouchable Batman is makes him sound like the new Chuck Norris meme, which is incredibly unfortunate but only serves to add to my hate.

I agree with this, and I considered putting him down as my answer, though honestly, what I hate most is this stupid narrative that Batman is the most ~realistic~ hero out of the lot just because he’s human, as if motivation is all it took for Bruce Wayne to become the Batman, or that Batman is somehow the one that people should aspire to be like the most. 

Ugh, good god, if I get one more asshole who insists their love of Batman is because of his “gritty realism” as a way to legitimize their own juvenile power fantasies as something attainable and therefore totally-mature-you-guys, I may spontaneously combust.

Man, I HATE the gritty realism :( I honestly can’t stand the Frank Millar branch of Bats, it’s so juvenile hiding behind adult themes. Batman stories first appealed to me because he’s a detective, they’re crime stories, but with a fantastical twist. The other superheros never really appealed to me because most of them were just fighters, more idealized brawn. My two childhood draws were Bats and Spidey, and that’s because they didn’t resort to see villain, fight villian, but a lot of their crime fighting involved investigations and sleuthing. Now there’s a lot of people who think Batman should be this supersmart brawler, but I much prefer the idea of him being in shadow 80% of the time. The mystery is what makes it great. 

It’s like an old coworker of mine at the comic store used to say about Batman Begins: While it’s a great movie, it’s a terrible BATMAN movie because he doesn’t spend any time doing detective work; he works out, pays for gadgets and fights people. 

Like everyone knows, I LOVE Batman. But I’m indifferent on Bruce Wayne, it’s the iconography I love. I love the POTENTIAL of Batman, the potential Batman and the rogues gallery have at telling good crime stories with just that extra fanatical twist. That’s why the Joker’s such a great villain - he’s skinny and frail but he’s a goddamn genius and sets up these elaborate schemes for try and foil Bats, but when the solution is for Bats to just punch through it I lose interest. 

I think that’s why I’m actually not a fan of Harley. On paper Harley’s a great character, a sort of emotional foil for Joker because it’s impossible for a character like Joker to be any sort of emotional, but then she’s trotted out like this giggling idiotic infantile character played mostly for comic relief with the ‘but wait she’s smart’ bone thrown in occasionally, and it’s just EXTREMELY FUCKING ANNOYING especially when you remember SHE’S SUPPOSED TO BE IN HER GODDAMN THIRTIES.The only version of Harley I’ve liked since BtAS has been the Arkham City version - the first game was still annoying with her idiotic whining. 

Also no one should try to be Bruce Wayne. Bruce Wayne is goddamn fucking insane. He dresses up like a Bat for heavens sake.

tl;dr I forgot what my point was. I’m still naming my first son Bruce.

(Source: gailsimone)

  1. cloudydrake reblogged this from gailsimone
  2. cloudydrake reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
    I have an aversion to Zatanna,...it’s plainly due to the fact that
  3. philippos42 reblogged this from romanadvoratrelundar and added:
    Note to self: Do not pitch your “Wildcat’s Nine Lives” concept to Gail Simone.
  4. spiral-shark reblogged this from coelasquid and added:
    Did you read that crossover from the Dark Wolverine comic side? It was actually pretty hilarious how close Frank got to...
  5. dreamsofawesome reblogged this from coelasquid and added:
    really just can not bring myself to...or care about John Stewart anymore. He’s always just...
  6. zombiemcqueen reblogged this from nekoama and added:
    I feel almost the same way. I love Batman - I’ve always loved him since I was a child, probably will always love him -...
  7. coelasquid reblogged this from electricmoshpit and added:
    I have absolutely hated him every time...crossed paths with titles I’ve actually wanted to...
  8. electricmoshpit reblogged this from coelasquid and added:
    idea behind Daken...actually pretty lame,...pretty cool...
  9. nekoama reblogged this from mayeko and added:
    Man, I HATE the gritty realism :( I honestly can’t stand the Frank Millar branch of Bats, it’s so juvenile hiding behind...
  10. celebrenithil said: Those two guys are clearly Marty Stus anyways. :)
  11. deepredroom reblogged this from coelasquid and added:
    those complaints apply...long-running comic characters.
  12. bunnybotbaby reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
    could pick up just...Wally was the Flash and have some reference
  13. baconisbetterthanbacon reblogged this from coelasquid and added:
    just caaaaaan’t get behind Wolverine...my own personal reasons (I hate knowing that...
  14. coelasquid reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
    I cannot stand Amadeus Cho, he ruins the otherwise enjoyable Hercules series for me. I feel like whenever Marvel...
  15. allthegreatnamesaretaken said: Hush. He’s shallow and I think his popularity has to do with being drawn by Jim Lee more than having a place in the batman comics.
  16. jongraywb reblogged this from kanenwriter and added:
    It’s one of the many reasons I guess I’m not really giving DC any of my cash right now. Honestly, everything about Hal...
  17. booklover81 said: I’ll probably be hung but Superman. I just don’t get all the optimism/Boy Scoutness. It’s not that I don’t like him, but his appeal is beyond me.
  18. romanadvoratrelundar reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
    irrational hatred of Wildcat.
  19. demios reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
    Members of the bat family I like… Bruce Wayne Dick Grayson Barbara Gordon Tim Drake Jason Todd Damian Wayne Ace Alfred...
  20. texasannie reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
    Donna Troy. I’ve tried,...just don’t get...think it might...
  21. krelllabs reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
    Venom (and by extension, Carnage and the other little Venoms). When Marvel began turning mass-murdering monsters into...
  22. comicbooksawesome said: Green Lantern. The whole Green Lantern part of the DCU actually. I don’t care for any of it.
  23. mayak46 reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
    Lana Lang & Betty Cooper....supposed to feel sorry for them. The poor girl next door...
  24. jovenistheworst reblogged this from doomismyname and added:
    FUCK YOU, NICK. OMAC IS THE BEST.
  25. hildebabble said: I just don’t understand the appeal of the Flash. Any of them.
  26. doctordisaster said: Cyclops. After arguing with a Cyke fan, I wrote this fake interview to explain my distaste: doctordisaster.tumblr.c… (In brief, he’s a “leader” with no leadership skills who is demonstrably a horrible person.)
  27. guyalice said: Damian Wayne and any Green Lantern except for Guy (and sometimes Kyle)
  28. katzedecimal said: Axel Walker aka “Trickster” II. I don’t think I’ve ever hated a character as vehemently as I hate Axel. But even if I keep my reasons to the professional level of writing & character direction, there aren’t enough Tumblr charas to explain it all.
  29. retro-nouveau said: Damian. Arrogant, sexist, conceited, spiteful, condescending, bitter, elitist - no respect for human life, for people’s feelings, not even for Alfred. Mean people suck.
  30. magnificentbastich reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
    think through the years it has to be - le gasp - Batman. Misinterpret me correctly: I love Bruce as a family member....
  31. notasamalander reblogged this from gailsimone and added:
    Wolverine. I know he’s...badass and he’s funny and blah blah blah blah, but the guy...